Editing Vs Proofreading – 5 Differences

Starting from English enthusiasts to commoners, editing and proofreading are the two terms that tend to confuse us all often. Well, it is quite justified as they have similar traits but there is a fine line of responsibilities and task differentiation between an editor and a proof-reader.

An editor is an individual who corrects the initial mistakes of a writer. For example, an editor is supposed to identify poorly constructed or insensible sentences. That individual has to understand whether the language used is appropriate for conveying the message it intends to or not.

On the other hand, a proofreader is someone who has to take up the role of grammar police and skim through all the errors in grammar or punctuation. For example, a proof-reader is held responsible for any and every spelling mistake or inconsistency in a sentence. It can either be numerical or textual; a proof-reader has to track it all.

Summarizing the differences between these two terms is a task on its own. However, here are some of the ways you can define editing and proofreading.

An editor has to rewrite when required

For an editor, it is difficult to work when the writer has unorganized paragraphs as it disrupts the flow of the paper. The writer then has to oblige by the rewriting policy to satisfy a client’s needs. Generally, proofreaders do not have to go through this hassle. They just correct the mistakes and are least bothered about the chronological order.

A proofreader has to go beyond systems to check a paper

Proofreaders have to abide by the manual and automatic spell checking since each and every mistake counts. From grammar to punctuation, the proof-reader has to go through and every word individually to figure out possible errors. It is extremely time-consuming and editors are not bound to do the same. They are more concerned about the content.

An editor provides clarity to the writing

It is very important for each and every paragraph to phrase to be clear enough to understand. The editor has to make sure that the reader does not struggle while reading the paper or is not confused with the idea it is trying to portray. Luckily, the proof-readers are mainly concerned with spelling and punctuation, not the meaning of the paper.

A proofreader ensures zero grammatical error

Editors are not usually bound to do spelling or grammar check. However, a proofreader is supposed to do both. A proof-reader has to make sure that there are no grammatical or punctuation mistakes since it hampers the readers’ experience of reading. This is a crucial job responsibility for a proof-reader and it is an inevitable task for them.

Incorporation of specialized knowledge by editors

An editor is allegedly responsible for adding extra or missing information to the text in order to make it look complete. This is usually done when the text is not up to the mark or lacks enough information. The editor will use his/her knowledge to fill in the gaps. A proof-reader only cares about the sentence structure, not what it describes.

In Conclusion, proofreading and editing are two different terms of the English Language. Both of the individuals have an important role to play when it comes to making a text perfect and appropriate although they are definitely not identical.

editing student documents

Additional sources

Leave a Comment

Related Posts

ALL TYPES OF COPY EDITING

All Types of Copy Editing

In the world of writing, there are several types of copy editing and  here we provide brief descriptions for each type of copy editing. Let’s assume you give your work to a copy-editor to work on it. The copy-editor after some days or weeks returns the work to you, and what you find is something…
Human proofreading vs. machine proofreading

Human Proofreading Vs. Machine Proofreading

Can the current proofreading tools/machine proofreading replace human proofreading? If this is your question, this article is for you! Towards the end of the 1990s, a chess-playing machine designed by IBM known as Deep Blue did an extraordinary thing; it beat the world chess champion, Garry Kasparov, in a chess match. What made this even…
What is copy editing?

What Is Copy Editing?

When it comes to writing, there’s a whole lot involved. Sure, curating the content takes the lion’s share of the work, but other subcategories of activities every written piece need before publishing or submission. Most of these subcategories are targeted towards editing. Editing is crucial for every caliber or writer as it ensures that the…
Common copy editing mistakes

Top 5 Common Copy Editing Mistakes

There are common copy editing mistakes that are well known to skilled copy editors. If you are thinking of making some copy editing changes on your own, you might want to avoid some of the following major copy editing mistakes. When self-editing, it really is easy to make some big mistakes that, to you, can…
Skills required for copy editing

Top 5 Skills Required for Copy Editing

If you ever intend on becoming a copy editor, then you need to know what you are actually doing. Many of us get involved in things like copy editing and improving our work without really knowing for sure if we are making the right calls. That is problematic, and it can often lead to making…