Problems with Open Access Journals

Like everything else evolving, the acceptance of open access journals among authors and readers increases tremendously by the day. As researchers, funders and publishers invest quite some in newer opportunities, open access journals sure come with lots of benefits. However, a few problems have been associated with this type of publication as well over the years.

Sadly, even with the multiple advancements implemented on open access models, these challenges cannot be ignored. Let’s look through a few problems associated with open access journals– pointing to why they aren’t as great as they claim. Shall we?

Open access journals

Research Quality of the Journals

The research quality of open access journals has been one of the most challenging defects associated with this publication. It’s been the lasting complaints of multiple open access journal readers across the globe for years. The increasing number of these publications is a major reason why there’s depreciation in quality yearly. For example, these journals’ poor backgrounds make identifying the source and credibility of each content almost impossible. (Which journal should I choose for my paper?)

Since the only requirement for getting your predatory journal published is the Article Processing Charge (APC), there’s no standard for scrutinizing these journals’ quality. Authors from several academic backgrounds, beliefs, ethics, and school of thought publish their journals on the open-access publication. Also, the authenticity of the research data and content of these journals cannot be guaranteed.


In the early century, perhaps self-archiving would have been an advantage of open access journals. However, it’s a disadvantage in this age, with other evolving innovations in storing published data. Open access models operate with a pre- or post-print only archive that stores and keep published data. To reduce cost, self-archiving helps investors save a lot while they still publish content. However, what’s the longevity of these journals?

Open access models are not the most secure and long-lasting as their hybrid alternative. Unlike the open-access models, hybrid journals tend to have up-to-date technology for storing the data for every journal before and after publishing. Although they could be a little more expensive than open access models, hybrid journals have better security and archive memory.

Exploitation by Predatory Publishers

This is a common challenge faced by the open-access business model. Predatory publishers are individuals who take advantage of open access models strictly to charge publication fees. Even when predatory publishers mandate these charges on authors, they fail to include the peer-review, editorial, and proofreading services in their delivery. Authors working on multiple publications per time expect that their journals are edited before publishing. Unfortunately, predatory publishers fail to meet their expectations.

Over time, predatory publishers have made numerous authors and readers doubt open access models’ credibility. It is now a known fact among authors and a large percentage of readers that open access journals have zero peer-reviewed before publication. We believe this to be more of a challenge to the model than predatory publishers. The predatory publishers exploit the credibility built by the model for their benefits, while open access loses its consumers yearly.

Why Go for Open Access Journals Then?

In conclusion, although open access journals come with these few challenging problems, the model is still trusted by many authors to date. It’s still the only model that offers wide-range visibility, lower publication costs, and trusted citations. Among authors, both young and old, we still choose and prefer that we could publish a lot of content for just a token article processing charge.

In Conclusion

As stated earlier on, the problem is the quality of these publications for authors looking to spam readers with numerous fake research and data. On the other hand, readers also get a wide range of quality content on open access journals without subscription costs. There are more than enough reasons for anyone to consider open access journals.

Keep reading our blog

Photo of author

By Andy Xavier

Andy is an avid content developer and writer. He is experienced in creating engaging articles that are entirely unique and insightful. He has written lots of articles for Scientific Editing since 2019.

Leave a Comment

Related Posts

What is a journal paper editing service?

What Is a Journal Paper Editing Service?

As a grad student, you may have asked “What is a journal paper editing service?” if you have looked for someone to check your paper before submission. You want to know what you can get from the service. Well then this post is for you. As an author, writer, or student, a journal paper is…
Hiring a Journal Paper Editing Service

Hiring a Journal Paper Editing Service

What Is a Journal Paper You maybe considering hiring a journal paper editing service if you have just finished writing your paper and now are looking for someone to go through your paper and catch your mistakes. Well then this article if for you. Journal papers contain articles written about specific topics, and they are…
Excluding reviewers from your paper

Excluding Reviewers from Reviewing Your Paper – Why & How?

Many authors choose to allow their manuscripts to not be accessible by “non-preferred reviewers,” who are specific individuals that fall under the category of people that authors don’t want them to receive their manuscripts for review. Excluding reviewers is a common practice greatly attributed to the fact that most authors consider some individuals as an…
Suggesting Peer Reviewers for your Paper

Suggesting Peer Reviewers for Your Paper

For over 300 years, the peer review validation method has been used by scholars to assess the quality of their work and research. Its major purpose has been to validate academic work, increase networking possibilities, and polish the quality of published research. Although this method has received some criticism, it is still the most popularly…
Mega journal definition

What Is a Mega Journal? Characteristics & Examples

Definition Mega journals are trendy in academic publishing. These scholarly journals are peer-reviewed open access journals, much larger than traditional journals, and subject to a less strict selection process. To understand the main idea behind Mega journals, one must first understand Open Access publishing (OA). Simply put, OA gives access to published information; this information…