Writing a Cover Letter

Here we have provided some simple tips to help you respond to reviewers‘ comments and get a positive decision!

Comprehend

When the decision letter arrives, read the comments carefully. Take time to understand the reviewers’ feedback and try to understand what they are asking you to do. It is also important to understand WHY they are asking you to do so. The Journal will give you a time frame for the revisions so don’t try to reply immediately.

Give yourself a while to process the feedback while you should be mindful to return your revisions with a timely response. By taking time, you let your emotions go away and prevent an impulsive response, which you would undoubtedly regret later.

Answer

One of the functions of peer review is to encourage the authors to deliver more robust research. After allowing yourself a day to process the comments, switch gears into “answer mode”! This is the time to trust your natural analytical processing skills. If you are still defensive rather than responsive, you are not ready yet to write a cover letter. Your responses should be polite and objective. There is no room for ego in your response. Start your cover letter by thanking the reviewers for pinpointing the weaknesses in your paper and providing you the opportunity to strengthen your research prior to publication.

The art of well-mannered rebuttal can be difficult to grasp but there is nothing inherently wrong about disagreeing on some of the reviewers’ points. Postulate your counter argument with a polite response that is  backed up with evidence to support your arguments.

Mindful

Being mindful and organized when you resubmit your manuscript allows the revision process to run smoothly and efficiently. Your resubmission should contain four things:

  1. Cover letter
  2. List of responses
  3. Track changes document
  4. Clean version

Revising your manuscript doesn’t have to be stressful. Keep calm and Good luck!

About Scientific Editing: (www.Scientific-editing.info): Scientific Editing is a trusted science editing company that provides editing and proofreading services for the global research community. Scientific Editing was established with a goal to accelerate international scientific research communication. At Scientific Editing, we take great effort to understand our authors’ needs. We aim to help scientists and academic authors break through the language barriers, bridge the gap between authors and peer-reviewed journals, and accelerate the process of publishing high-quality articles.

editing student documents

Useful sources

Photo of author

By Bizhan Romani

Dr. Bizhan Romani has a PhD in medical virology. When it comes to writing an article about science and research, he is one of our best writers. He is also an expert in blogging about writing styles, proofreading methods, and literature.

Leave a Comment

Related Posts

What is a conjunction

What is a Conjunction? Definition & Examples

What does a conjunction do?Where is a conjunction used?What is a conjunction? Here we have answers to all these questions! Conjunctions, one of the English parts of speech, act as linkers to join different parts of a sentence. Without conjunctions, the expression of the complex ideas will seem odd as you will have to use…
Adverb, definition, examples

What Is an Adverb? Definition & Examples

Introduction An adverb is a word that modifies a sentence, verb, or adjective. An adverb can be a word or simply an expression that can even change prepositions, and clauses. An adverb usually ends only- but some are the same as their adjectives counterparts. Adverbs express the time, place, frequency, and level of certainty. The…
What are run-on sentences?

What Are Run-on Sentences?

When two whole sentences are fused together without the use of a coordinating conjunction, run-on sentences, also known as fused sentences, occur. They’re sentences that include too many ideas and don’t use correct punctuation like a period or a semicolon to separate them. Short or lengthy sentences can be run-ons, although not all long phrases…
What is a pronoun?

What Is a Pronoun?

What is a pronoun?How is a pronoun used in a sentence?What are all types of pronouns? A pronoun is classified as a transition word and a subcategory of a noun that functions in every capacity that a noun will function. They can function as both subjects and objects in a sentence. Let’s see the origin…
compound sentences complex sentences

Compound Sentences and Complex Sentences

In the English language, sentence construction is quite imperative to understanding. A sentence can be a sequence, set or conglomerate of words that is complete in itself as it typically contains a subject, verb, object and predicate. However, this sentence regardless of its intent, would be chaotic if not constructed properly. Proper sentence construction helps…